Karbala
A two-perspective journey · 60–61 AH
Map key
Shared — both traditions
Sunni transmission
Shia transmission
Where the traditions part
Later devotion — not in the earliest sources
Source-criticism (academic layer)
Shared — both traditions
Sunni transmission
Shia transmission
Where the traditions part
Later devotion — not the earliest sources
Source-criticism (academic layer)
Timeline — the journey · 41–61 AH
{{ capHint }}
{{ activeTitle }}
{{ activeDate }}
{{ headerMeta }}
{{ activeTitle }}
{{ activeDate }}
{{ counterLabel }}
{{ ll.label }}
41 AH — the treaty
61 AH — Ashura & memory
{{ p.label }}
Chapter
{{ toastName }}
{{ toastDate }}
{{ toastText }}
{{ card.chipLabel }}

{{ card.title }}

{{ card.dateLine }}
Later devotional addition — beloved in remembrance, but not in the earliest sources. Shown for completeness, not as established record.
{{ card.summary }}
{{ card.learn }}
“{{ card.quote }}”
{{ card.attribLine }}
WHERE THE TRADITIONS PART · {{ cardDiv.id }}
{{ cardDiv.question }}
SUNNI READING
{{ cardDiv.sunni }}
SHIA READING
{{ cardDiv.shia }}
The paths reconverge: both traditions carry the story onward together. Neither reading is adjudicated here.
{{ card.confLabel }}
{{ card.citation }}
{{ locatorNote }}
CLOSING
Both traditions end in the same place: that al-Husayn was killed unjustly, and died a martyr. What they weigh differently is blame, and trust, and how the day should be mourned. You have travelled the road twice over, sometimes on one path and sometimes on two. The split paths are not a flaw in the record — they are the record, honestly shown: two communities remembering one grief, and inviting you to hold both in view.
— To revisit any moment, drag the map or the timeline. To see who recorded it, and how surely, turn on the academic layer.
 City

{{ cardCity.name }}

{{ cardCity.translit }}
{{ cardCity.role }}
{{ cardCity.blurb }}
MOMENTS HERE
{{ e.title }}
Sources & further reading
Every cited work opens at a stable, public location — ḥadīth at sunnah.com, the histories at the Internet Archive. No copyrighted text is hosted here.
{{ locatorNote }}
{{ s.title }}
{{ s.author }} · {{ s.access }}
{{ s.note }}
{{ tourStepLabel }}
{{ tourTitle }}
{{ tourBody }}
60–61 AH · 680 CE

Karbala

A journey told from two traditions at once

In the year 60 of the Hijra — 680 of the Common Era — a grandson of the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ set out across the desert and did not return. His name was al-Husayn ibn Ali. Within a few months he would be dead, with almost all the men of his family, on a waterless plain beside the Euphrates called Karbala.

The story is remembered by all Muslims, but it is not remembered in only one way. This is a map of that journey told from two traditions at once — the Sunni transmission, gathered by historians like Ibn Kathir, and the Shia transmission, preserved from the earliest dedicated account, that of Abu Mikhnaf. Where the two agree, you will travel a single road. Where they part, the road forks before your eyes, and you can follow either telling.

Drag across the land from city to city. Move through the days from a contested oath to the morning of Ashura. Open any moment to hear it in the words of those who recorded it.

SUNNI TRANSMISSION
Ibn Kathir's al-Bidāya wa'l-Nihāya with Ibn Hajar — cross-checked against mainstream Sunni scholarship.
SHIA TRANSMISSION
Abu Mikhnaf's earliest dedicated account, as carried by al-Ṭabarī (tr. Howard).
Where the traditions agree you travel one road; where they part, the road forks — neither telling is judged.
Sources are deep-linked to their public homes, never hosted.
{{ introHint }}
The map could not load
{{ loadError }}